Many Homes that were built within the last 2 decades in Northern Virginia were mass produced and, as a result, there is usually a need to replace wood trim that was of low grade, or which was installed poorly. Moreover, a sub-par roofing job provided by the original Builder will almost always lead to problems with the Wood Trim and paint that was designed to protect it.
We recently just replace parts of a Fascia Board that had deterioration because the drip edge of the shingles were installed flush with the fascia boards. To add to the deterioration problem our Carpenter discovered additional deterioration within the actual framing. There was evidence of leaking within the attic and obvious rotted Facia Board Trim that all needed to be replaced on the Exterior.
The Homeowner wanted to preserve the original features of Home, specifically, the Porch. My take preference would be to replace the rotted wood with wood. However, everyone was concerned about the long-term maintenance. We ended up installing installing new Gutters under the drip edge, so that should fix the problem with water flowing over the fascia. We then thoroughly examined the remaining Wood Trim of the Exterior and I am very confident that this Homeowner will not have additional carpentry issues in the future.